Skip to content

Think from the market in, not the product out

The most common business mistake is thinking outward from your product. The market does not wait for you. You start where it already is, and you design back from there.

8 min read

Most marketing is made for the person making it. The business owner creates content they find interesting, sells the features they find impressive, addresses the objections they imagine are important. They are not wrong that these things matter. They are wrong about whose judgement counts.

The prospect does not care about your product's features. They care about their own situation: the problem they are living with, the outcome they most want, the specific fear that makes them hesitate. Your product is relevant only insofar as it touches those things. Marketing that starts from the product and moves toward the prospect will always be less persuasive than marketing that starts from the prospect's existing experience and moves toward the product. The sequence determines everything.

Start with the desire that already exists

The most common failure in marketing is trying to create desire for a product rather than finding the desire that already exists and connecting your product to it. Creating desire is expensive and slow. Connecting to existing desire is fast and cheap. The product that fits a desire the market already has does not need to explain why the desire is worth having. It simply needs to demonstrate that it is the best vehicle for getting there.

This requires a form of enquiry most businesses skip. Instead of asking "how do I explain what my product does?", the productive question is "what does my ideal customer already want, fear, and secretly dream of, and how does what I offer connect to that?". The answer requires getting close to real customers, talking to the people who bought and the people who did not, reading what they write when they are not talking to you, absorbing the language they use to describe their own problems.

The exact language a prospect uses to describe their problem is more valuable than any copywriting formula, because it is the language that lands as recognition rather than as information. Recognition converts. Information does not. When a prospect reads a headline and thinks "that is exactly what I have been dealing with", the sale is already largely made.

Know the person, not the demographic

Demographics are categories. People are individuals. Copy addressed to a demographic speaks to no one in particular and moves no one with any urgency. Copy addressed to a specific individual, describing their specific situation, naming their specific fear, and pointing toward their specific desired outcome, feels like it was written exclusively for them, and that feeling is the mechanism of conversion.

Before writing a word of copy, you need to know the specific human being you are writing to with enough depth to name them, describe their political beliefs, list their daily irritations, name the specific thing they are most afraid of, and articulate the outcome they most want and are most reluctant to say out loud. An avatar defined by three or more overlapping dimensions, age, profession, specific pain, specific interest, produces copy and outreach that makes prospects think "I cannot believe they know this about me." That recognition is what converts.

The fastest route to this depth is direct conversation with the people who have already bought and the people who decided not to. The exact language that makes a prospect's eyes light up during a call is the language that should lead every ad, every landing page, every sales script. Most founders systematically avoid these conversations. The avoidance costs them enormously in every piece of marketing they produce without that input.

Subcultures trump broad markets

Every broad market fractures into niches, and every niche fractures into subcultures, and members of each level self-identify most strongly with the narrowest category they belong to. A fitness enthusiast is not just interested in fitness. They are a CrossFitter, or a powerlifter, or someone who follows a particular approach to nutrition. Marketing that speaks to "people interested in fitness" lands weakly. Marketing that speaks directly to the specific subculture, in the specific language that community uses, with the specific references and concerns that community shares, lands as insider recognition rather than as advertising.

This is not a small difference in effectiveness. It is an order-of-magnitude difference. The more precisely your marketing language matches the specific subculture, the more the audience feels you are talking to them specifically rather than broadcasting at everyone within the category. That feeling of being specifically seen is the precondition for trust, and trust is the precondition for conversion.

Operating from personal wants rather than market needs

There is a failure mode that appears repeatedly in businesses built by people who are skilled at making things: operating the business based on what the owner finds interesting, impressive, or worth doing, rather than on what the market demonstrably wants. This is understandable. The thing you make is connected to your identity. You believe in it. You built it because you thought it mattered. But the market does not buy things because the maker believed in them. It buys things because the product addresses something it cares about in a form it can recognise.

The corrective is to impose a formal discipline of separating two questions that most businesses conflate: "what do I want to make?" and "what does the market want to buy?" Answering the first question is easy because it draws on enthusiasm and expertise. Answering the second requires getting outside your own head and into the documented, verified reality of your audience's experience. The discipline of doing that regularly, not once at launch but continuously, is the practice that keeps a market-in orientation from decaying back into product-out over time.

Nostalgia, aspiration, and the emotional origin of purchase

One dimension of market understanding that most businesses miss is the emotional architecture underneath the rational desire. People have nostalgia not only for how things were, but for an idealised version of the past that may never quite have existed. The emotion lives in the gap between memory and feeling, not in the accurate reconstruction of events. A product that connects to that felt sense of something lost, something simpler, something before the current complexity, is not selling a feature. It is selling a psychological resolution.

Similarly, aspiration is not a straightforward projection of "I want to be like this person." It is a more complex relationship with a version of themselves the prospect has been told is possible but has not yet achieved. Understanding which specific version of themselves the prospect is most urgently trying to become, and where the gap between their current self and that version is most painfully felt, produces a quality of targeting precision that demographic research cannot supply.

What changes when you start from the market

The character of your creative work changes entirely. Instead of describing your product's features and waiting for the prospect to translate them into relevance, you describe the prospect's situation, their experience, their frustration, their aspiration, and you show how your product slots into that. The prospect does not have to do the work of translation. You have already done it.

The quality of the intelligence you bring to every subsequent decision improves too. When you know your customer deeply, you know which channels they actually use, which messages actually land, which offers address the real concern rather than the imagined one. Every piece of the marketing system improves, not because you became a better technical marketer, but because you are now working with accurate information about the person you are trying to reach.

The efficiency of your product development improves as well. The business that understands its market deeply does not build features and then discover whether the market wants them. It understands, in advance, which problems are felt most acutely, which trade-offs the customer is most willing to make, and which promise would, if kept reliably, produce the loudest word-of-mouth. That knowledge produces product decisions with a higher prior probability of being right, and fewer expensive mistakes made in the dark.

Up next · Lesson 08

If your prospect can compare you to anyone else, you have already lost on price

If your prospect can directly compare you to anyone else, you have already lost on price. The whole game is to make that comparison impossible.

Read next →